Letters to SuperModels, March 31, 2004
Responses
to column --
"For
American Brands, the world turns ugly."
**
I'm sure if we continue to be sensitive morons we will end up like
the French. It just goes to show that we have no friends. The world
should kiss our ass for the sacrifices we've made. I'd rather be
feared than liked. That's the price of leadership.
I think we should ask the European leaders if they would like us to
leave their countries. We could leave small contingents of troops and
redeploy them to where they're needed most. I could think of a few. I
wonder what the world would say when we controlled the oil. Or maybe
that's all the world is worried about. I wonder if the world really
cares about mankind and the future. Let them all sit in their cafe,
smoke and get cancer. -- Wyrms67
--
As an American who has lived and worked in Europe for some 20
years, and has strong ties to Europe going back another decade prior,
I cannot help but feel that you had your finger on the pulse of things
when writing this article.I have never previously encountered such
animosity towards things American as I have in the last 18 months, and
not only within the European Union, but also in Eastern European
nations, and even in the likes of Switzerland where people are not
typically noted for taking heated political views regarding any other
country.
I can imagine, without knowing better, that the US press has not
been quick to point out the anger publicly expressed by British
companies when they found that they were to play second fiddle to US
companies as regards reconstruction contracts in Iraq ---- and this in
spite of the UK being the US' "special partner" during the Iraq
hostilities.
Anyone who feels that the current US foreign policies will not
impact on current and future sales of American products and services
abroad is kidding himself. The world has clearly developed a 'them and
us' attitude, not surprising in light of a US president telling
foreigners that they 'are either with us or against us'. -- John
Sturgeon, Great Britain
--
Jon -- As an American living in New Zealand I read your article on
US brands abroad with interest. Anti US feelings here go back pre GW
Bush. Living here on the bottom of the planet in the most British
country outside Britain I read a lot of columns from here and also
from UK publications such as the Observer and the Guardian.
Journalism outside the US I feel is more opinionated and subjective
than US news. I have in the last 4 years here read daily negative
andcritical articles about many facets of US lifestyle that are very
twisted in the way the facts are presented . The list is long and
here's just a few.
The breakfast food market is dominated by 3 companies who price fix
and drive smaller competitors out. All American's drive large SUV's
and big 8 cylinder cars an pollute the air. Americans don't get
anyinternational news and know nothing outside of their country. The
American form of government is based on a outdated Constitution
andother nations governmental bodies such as the UK parliament is a
more effective form of government. America is out to destroy the
agriculture of the world with GMO's. This goes on and on. But as they
rubbish the US they all look at the US market as the ONE.
When the US dollar goes down against the AU or NZ dollar thats
terrible as it impacts their ability to sell in the US against US
manufacturersand farmers. So yes they think negative thoughts about
the US but then demand more trade access for their goods.The biggest
export market here for export beef is the US but if you ask people
they would say Europe or Japan which buy together maybe 25% of what
the US buys . So they don't even know how big a customer the US is of
their products.
A lot of the mis-information comes from TV media which seems to
select the worst of a days events in the US. I guess its like watching
DanRather say how bad the economy is and then watching CNBC for
several hours and hearing details about how the economy is growing.But
US brands are here the new and old, GM Australia makes the most
popular cars for both NZ and AU markets, with Ford no2 in AU and 3 in
NZ. Both have been in these markets for well over 70 years.
Westinghouseappliances, Mobil, Caltex, Valvoline, AC, CRC, DAP,
Planters peanuts, Californian citrus, raisins, Hunts BBQ sauce, Coke,
Pepsi, Oceanspray. I have lived here several times and there are more
US consumer goods for sale here then at any time in the past. US
computer and software firms dominate.
But these markets are years behind US consumers in a variety of
products and services. Theres a new Krispy Kreme store in Sydney thats
not doing well because.... they don't eat doughnuts in these places,
not familiar with them. Starbucks are primarily in tourist areas, Taco
Bell opened several stores in Sydney and are closing some. Consumers
don't eat Mexican. I guess the moral of the story is that just because
it works in the US you can't expect it to work outside the US. There
are 600 Fish and Chip shops in New Zealand. Thats probably how many
there are in the US.
Tyco by the way having gone on its buying binge of all varieties of
companies has all sorts of divisions here and know one recognizes it
as a US firm.
Overall I think the US is guitly of being too nice and gets
ex[;poted in trade, currency manipulation and is sometimes naive in
its appreciation of other countries who don't appreciate it. – Dean
Tatro
--
THE LIST OF COUNTRIES YOU MENTIONED ON THE MOST PART ARE COUNTRIES
THAT EITHER ARE ISLAMIC & HATE FREEDOM FOR THEIR CITIZENS OR COUNTRIES
THAT DON'T HAVE THE GUTS TO STAND UP AGAINST EVIL.
I COULD CARE LESS HOW THEY FEEL ABOUT US! IN THE END THE US IS THE
GREATEST HOPE FOR WORLD PEACE & PROSPERITY. – JACK R.
--
You failed to point out in your column that much of this began
about 6 years ago when we invaded Jugoslavia and baombed the Chinese
Embassy, the Aspirin factory in the Sudan and the generally "bad
light" the Leader of the free world was shining by lieing under oath
in a federal courtroom. Also when the EU sees the US government gouge
Microsoft don't you think they want in on a little action from the
best co in the world as well? – BJSKWASH
--
I FEEL THIS ARTICLE IS PURE LEFT-WING GARBAGE. IF ANYTHING, I AM
NOW ENCOURAGED TO BUY MORE OF THE COMPANIES YOU MENTIONED. IT'S BAD
ENOUGH THAT THE AMERICAN PUBLIC HAS TO BE EXPOSED TO THE LIBERAL MEDIA
IN ITS NEWS STORIES---DO WE NOW HAVE TO FACE IT IN THE BUSINESS SECTOR
AS WELL?
PEOPLE OF OTHER COUNTRIES HAVE MORE RESPECT FOR US NOW (THE
CONSUMERS) SINCE WE HAVE TAKEN A STAND AGAINST TERRORISM. OF COURSE
THAT IS NOT REFLECTED IN OUR NEWS MEDIA; ALL WE HEAR ABOUT ARE THE
WEAK-KNEED "LEADERS" OF SOME FOREIGN COUNTRIES WHO ARE AFRAID OF THEIR
OWN SHADOWS WHO TALK LARGE BUT PERFORM SMALL.
COMPANIES LIKE PROCTOR & GAMBLE WILL CONTINUE TO PERFORM WELL
BECAUSE THEY PRODUCE & MARKET QUALITY PRODUCTS---WHETHER YOU'RE A
CITIZEN OF THE UNITED STATES, RUSSIA, OR FRANCE. I DON'T SEE THAT
CHANGING. THANKS FOR LISTENING. -- TERRY WEBER
--
Well, we should be an isolationist country. We give everything away
and give those so called wine bags who want our jobs a free ride. I
say good bye to Globalisim. Being Global stinks, and it is eroding our
(America's) way of life, not to mention our economy. – Godzilla
--
Jon, your article reflects a true picture of what USA is today.
However a worsening of USA image abroad is a fact with unforeseeable
consequences. Since the fall of communism, USA had a golden
opportunity to shape the planet according their own wishes, instead of
pushing to extreme capitalistic profit oriented setting. The times
when USA was regarded as the great and good friend are long gone...
when Kissinger said USA don't have friends but only interests around
the world, this is a worrysome sympton.
USSR collapsed because its citizens lost trust in their government,
and the mass comunication played an important role in all that. Now we
have USA as the most powerful country, but many countries around the
world have lost trust in them, not only at government level but also a
average citizen level. Mass comunication plays an important role in
all this. The fact that USA tries to defend their supremacy with
military power could backfire. Diplomacy and acceptance of chances are
key factors, like another economic reality like EU, rising of China
and India.
Terrorism is handled in the wrong way. Terrorism needs to be
studied and investigated as effect not as cause. If you don't conquer
the mind and heart of a billion muslins, you are bound for defeat.
Look the last century when Lenin and Hither were wanted by police as
criminals, no one would ever imagined they would leave and indelible
mark in the recent history, so who can predict what influence has some
terrorists leaders on the Islam.
In short and long term I don't see any reversed trend on the USA
situation around the world. I have not idea what the solution would
be, maybe it is a historic cycle. -- Bruno Gasparini
--
Jon -- Excellent article. I think though you have either ignored or
are unaware of the growing resentment in Canada. We are the closest
neighbor and a long time trading partner. In fact if you fill a room
with people from both countries it is often difficult to to tell who
is from where. Short sighted politicians, bent upon re-election and
isolationist executive ideology has done much to create mistrust
across our border. The ongoing lumber issues, fisheries etc. the US is
being seen as a bully simply consumed with self interests. The rest of
the world watches - and thinks. If the US is happy to screw their
nearest neighbor and best trading partner on a whim - why would they
want to foster closer relations. Their is an old biblical saying that
goes something like "Ye shall reap what ye sow". I think this is
exactly what you are seeing now.
I hope it doesn't last long because I think we are all in the same
leaky old boat - I have great friends in many parts of the US
and I hope they think they have a great friend in Canada. I like the
country and the people - it's time for some reflection by the
executive. We will stand shoulder to shoulder with our neighbors
against many evils, but it is always nicer when you don't have to
watch for that knife coming from the rear. Keep up the introspective,
thoughtful articles. -- Michael Mills
--
Sir -- Read your column, and in many ways I echo your sentiments.
Do you ever watch the Simpsons? They had a good skit that about summed
it up....The Simpsons ended up at a private school, and their
precosious daughter Lisa was looking into one of the classrooms from
an outside windown. She was marveling at the computers and overall
cleanliness of the school. Next to her pops up Springfield
Elementary's Principal Skinner. He points out that this school's
Periodic Element chart goes all the way up to #138, where as theirs
only gets up to #59. Lisa then goes on to say that Springfield
Elemenatry could get the same type of modern classroom aids, all they
would have to do is issue a bond. As she explains the bond, Skinner
throws a cinder block through the classroom's window, jumps in, and
starts handing Lisa anything he can lift. She says "Principal Skinner,
what you're doing is nothing more than stealing!" His
reply....."Welcome to Dick Cheney's America". And he's right. --
Brendon Bookman
--
So world opinion of the United States is sinking to new lows? Guess
what? I think the world outside the U.S. needs an enema. They continue
to plunder our "natural resources", (e.g. jobs) and take our handouts,
yet they bite the hand that feeds them. Without our support and
sacrifice, many "free" nations would now be either communistic,
dictatorships, or Nazi ruled. They sit back and watch as terrorists
commit atrocity after atrocity. They have cost our economy billions of
dollars and thousands of our citizens have died due to world opinion.
Spain for example, backed Hitler during World War II.
Why should they be any different now? They have no backbone and
likely never will. Frankly we should back off and watch the economy of
other nations crumble and their societies become utter chaos and
corrupt. Tell the "World" to clean their own backyards before they
accuse us of anything. They have more than enough skeletons in their
own closets to be putting us down. Guess what it really is? It is
fear. They fear us, and they fear each other as well. We don't need
them as much as they need us. -- Timothy M. Borland
--
Thank you for your excellent article. Some of the discussion taking
place regarding the MSFT EU conflict supposed that recent EU actions
against MSFT involved both punishment for the preeminence of the
company and irritation with our government. Consumers are hardly
helped by the ruling and there is virtually no European software
industry to protect. Hopefully, those industries whose businesses are
taking a hit will find it in their interests to support a change of
leadership in Washington. -- Carol Davidek-Waller
--
Gee, I didn't know you were a political commentator? Unpopular
pursuit of the Iraq war? According to who? Surely not the Iraqi
people. You must be talking about Sadamm ruthless hitmen? Martha
scandal? I didn't know people overseas cared so much? Doesn't matter
that you lie correct? Chalmers Johnson? He told an audience we should
all move to Canada and buy a condo. -- E Nichols
--
Hello -- what would be interesting for me to know is:
. Did applications for visas to the USA go down?
2. Are applications for immigration into the USA going down?
3.. Are less tourists visiting the USA?
4. Is Hollywood exporting less movies to the world?
5. Are Moslems leaving the USA (besides those who are being kicked
out)?
I assume (I don't have numbers here), that the answers to all
questions are "NO". So, I wouldn't be to concerned about the negative
attitude towards the USA at the moment. It was much more negative
during the Vietnam war. The declining Dollar makes US products more
competitive. Countries who have come to be accustomed to freely export
to the USA, now see imports (competition) from the USA surging in
their countries while they get less value for their exports to the USA
(because of the declining Dollar). Higher competition is not a love
affair.
Example 1: I have severe doubts that Boeing will sell less planes
compared to its main competitor, the european Airbus (at the huge
currency advantage Boeing has now).
Example 2: Over the last 5-7 years US cars have virtually
disappeared from the Israeli market (except for military, government
etc. where Israel is bound by contracts to "buy American"). I cannot
buy the Chevrolet Astra (or GMC Safari) van I am driving anymore as it
is no longer imported (price and fuel consumption much to high)...On
the other hand, recently, Chevrolet small passenger cars are gaining
market share. They are made in Korea (I think GM bought Hundai)...and
in countries where America is hated GM will probably keep the Hundai
brand.
With other words: Many foreign brands are american owned and the
international consumer doesn't care, doesn't even know it.
Nevertheless, on the long term, the main steady friends of the USA
will probably be "smaller" countries who are threatened by the big
blocks like China, India, Russia, the Islamic countries and the EC
(examples: Taiwan, Georgia, Israel, most African States except the
Islamic ones, Australia, New Zealand, Switzerland, Norway, Sri Lanka,
Japan, Vietnam, Laos etc.). Those of the big blocks will become pro-american
when they are threatened by another big block (example: more islamic
terrorist attacks in Europe and India like the one in Madrid will draw
the EC and India closer to the USA). I am not saying Bush and America
are modern Machiavellis, but it wouldn't be the most stupid policy to
act machiavellian, when a power block like China tries to take over
the world by taking over its industrial base.
Some american brands are just plain unhealthy: Coca Cola and
McDonalds are the best examples...but they seem to have understood
this lesson and are enlarging their "diet" to healthier products. --
Emanuel B. Krauskopf
--
In what world do you live? I've never read such hogwash in my life.
Clue! Spend a little more time making sure you ramblings have a
point that your examples support, or better yet, vaguely relate to.
You exemplify why the American public holds journalists with the
same regard that you claim the world markets hold U.S. foreign policy.
"Can" the Bush Bashing liberal bias. I hope to see better from you
in the future. I think you can do it. – L. Tisdale
--
If they want to boycott our products let them....all our products
help employ their people. How stupid are they....yes boycott Coca Cola
and thenCoke will lay off all their employees in that country. –
Brian Kirk
--
You article about the world not buying our products is rhetoric
from the left. When you are number 1 in anything everyone wants to
take you down, we need to stand strong and united on all fronts
including economics. The same people who yell at the US for this are
the same who want us to by their products, let’s see if they want to
get into that sort of pissing match. (Which does know one any good).
Quit trying to scare Americans to vote a certain way. – Dan
Fasbinder
--
Jon -- Your recent article "For American Brands, the World Turns
Ugly" like so many others in the media tries to paint American foriegn
policy as the catylist for the world to hate Americans. I am not sure
how well traveled you are, have you ever lived in a foriegn country or
just visited? I have been in the military for nearly 18 years and have
visited and lived all over the world so let me give you some insight.
Most ordinary people in the world only know America from the media
which like American media bashes American policy abroad daily. Despite
this fact most ordinary people around the world dont give a hoot and
once they meet an American for the first time there attitude, with the
exception of France, changes. What they see is a nation to include the
government that is willing to help people around the world even when
it has nothing to do with us or our borders.
This my friend is a good thing, because if we didnt genicide would
run a muck. We as Americans will never please everyone so there is no
reason to try, we should always try to do the right thing. As for your
article, lets face it most so called American products sold overseas
are made overseas like Ford. So the bottomline, if Europeans dont buy
Fords not one job in the States will be lost. The best possible
solution is to take a hint from Japan and Tariff the heck out of
products so like BMW, they will open a plant in the US and employ
American workers, Since in the end the only thing that matters is that
Joe and Sally down the street have a job and can provide for their
family. I like most Americans could care less about corparate
executives filling there pockets. Furthermore, if you took a poll in
America we Americans dont like many Europeans all that much either. So
why bash the home team, spend your time like media overseas and point
out their flaws, lord knows they have allot of them too. -- Evan
--
You mean other countries hate us??? What a suprise! I can't
understand why Islamic nations hate us?? First who cares? Second,
their going to buy our goods for the simple reason we are the best. I
do have a question though. This judgement against Microsoft by the EU.
Does Microsoft have to abide by this judgement? I'm thinking about the
World Court saying we have to overturn the verdicts of a few Mexicans
on death row here. Of course we're not going to. Jealousy sure is
ugly. -- Curt Massie
--
Are you one of those liberals, who think the world's troubles are
caused by the U S.? In my opinion, much of the anti-americanism
expressed around the world is cause by our own liberally biased news
media. When was the lase time you heard one of the major networks give
even a hint of pride in America and what we are doing to combat
tyrants and evil around the world. They like to use the excuse that
they must be objective. That's a lot of crap. … Since I didn't finish
your article, I don't know if you have expressed any of that pride
yourself. – Paul Haddaway
--
Excellent column. Sad but mostly true. The Warren Buffet fans I'm
sure hate to see these multi-national retailers and manufacturers get
picked on! -- Doug.
--
Mr. Markman: Could it be that our so called "european trading
partners" never had any goodwill towards us in the first place. Sure,
their markets have been open to us for a very long time, but mostly
out of necessity. After WWII europe was in shambles, we were the only
nation left with a strong manufacturing base and we did not have to
worry about rebuilding. Slowly, over the last fifty years they have
been on the road to economic recovery and they could very well be on
the verge of economic independence, able to establish their own
markets, leaving us in the dust. For once the American dollar is
experiencing strong competition from other currencies and if the
europeans/asians stick together, buy only european/asian goods, the
long term effects on our economy will be interesting to see. We go to
their aid during WWII and now they turn on us. Talk about gratitude. I
for one wish that our political leadership would close all foreign
military bases, bring all those soldiers and military equipment home.
Think of all the money our government could save. Once we are gone the
Russians and Chinese will start flexing their muscles and we can sit
back and watch the show when our "trading partners" get their
collective asses kicked. If the South Koreans think we have made the
peninsula more dangerous why not leave and let the North Koreans
invade the south bringing their communist philosophy, famine and
suffering. As for the muslim world, they never have and never will
have any use for the west. What amazes me is that all these european
and asian countries who are railing against us because of our middle
eastern policies do not seem to have the mental capacity to understand
that to a muslim they are also fair game, hence, the bombings in
Spain, etc. If they think that by comdemning us they are gaining the
favor of the muslim world they are in for a rude awakening. A muslim
has only one allegiance, that is to his faith.
The two countries that would really scare me the most (economically
speaking) would be Russia and China. At this point in time they are
not an economic threat to anyone but if those governments ever
ventured from beneath the ignorance of communism/socialism (which they
never will) and allowed free markets to reign. Can you imagine what
they could do by tapping their vast natural resources, especially the
Russians. That's where my money would be. – J. Chavez
--
What would have us do, old buddy--kiss up to the muslim bastards
who are trying their best to accomplish world domination?
Right now, I don't care much for Russians, Frenchmen, Germans,
Spaniards, Indonesians, Iraqis, Saudi Arabians, Syrians, Chinese,
Palestinians and a lot of others. I imagine that many Americans feel
the same way. Why don't you report on that?
You Democrats will do anything to try to make President Bush look
bad. Why don't you get a life? – R. Kuyrkendall
--
Jon -- If what your experts are saying is accurate, then we have
only ourselves to blame. No other countrymen are as critical of their
own country as Americans. We air our ‘dirty laundry’ in public for the
entire world to see. We fight, argue, name-call, and disparate each
other like no other entity. And, if we are to believe many of the
things we read in the city newspapers and what we see on national TV
each evening, I think I would lean toward self-hatred of my own
country too.
Why do our media concentrate on all the negatives aspects of our
culture? Why do we continue to be barraged with daily negative images
of ourselves? Why do we allow this chronic behavior of
self-deprecation to continue? Why do so many immigrants still want to
migrate to the US and the western world? Why do some European
countries have almost 20% of its population identified as Muslim? Do
Muslim groups routinely condemn the violence perpetrated in their
namesake or do they welcome? Do they really hate us and our products
or are they just trying to use this as another method to compete? Is
it easy to hate than to love or respect?
Why don’t your fellow journalists and scholars start a dialogue to
debate and address the real issues and come up with real solutions
instead of just bashing our society?
Of course, it’s easy to criticize, but much harder to come up with
solutions. I receive frequent emails from moveon.org telling me how
bad President Bush is and how he is leading us into the gates of hell
with such comments as "Please stop the reckless Bush budget”; likewise
on the other side about presidential candidate Kerry. If we hate
ourselves (or project that image), can we expect better from the rest
of the world? -- J. Lanzetta
--
Today's article on Ugly Americanism was a bell-ringer. I've been
feeling this way for at least two years, and it's been a lonely wait.
Glad to observe I'm not alone - and also feeling a sense of
vindication.
My hawkish friends seem to believe the best way to win friends and
benefit world affairs is to insult and smite them. The psychopathic
supposition is that admiration rises out of fear. It's a pity more
Americans do not travel abroad (other than at Club Med, that is), so
they could meet foreign people and learn these lessons firsthand, and
early-on, instead of after years of warfare and generations of enmity.
But our countrymen seem to be peculiarly myopic that way.
Am I correct in the opinion that, aside from piddling little police
actions like Grenada, the Iraq Redux campaign is the first time the
American military has invaded a soverign foreign nation since Teddy
Roosevelt and the Spanish-American war, circa 1898 ?
Am I also correct in the opinion that you also are no friend of the
conceited dimwit GWBush? Since when did arrogance become interpreted
as 'leadership'? It's outrageous. Is it also correct that upon the
first day of his stepping into the Oval Office, Iraq was first on the
agenda?..... an intention no doubt to correct the monumental screwup
of his spineless and idiotic daddy? Am I correct in the opinion that
GWBush is no more than a mouthpiece for the machine politicians of
power and privliege behind him? And I the only one seeing a striking
similarity between Dubya and Howdy Doody?
Are you still insulted by the echoes of the senior Bush proclaiming
that he could "feel our pain" during economic travails of his time -
this from a man who had no need to pilot his own car for twenty years?
Everyday Americans have absolutely nothing in common with that kind fo
person, yet we swallowed that spin whole. -- Brian |